Why is button three on trumpet almost never used alone?












2















The trumpet buttons 1,2 and 3 lowers the pitch by 2,1 and 3 halfsteps. So pressing button 1 and 2 gives the same result as only pressing the third button.



So why is the third button so rarely used alone? Why press two buttons instead if you don't have to? I have seen it be used for fast drills that would be almost impossible otherwise, but I cannot understand why it isn't the default for playing the notes E and A.










share|improve this question























  • In my youth and during the military service I always used the fingersttings like you discribed. One reason is mentioned in my answer. Another reason could be that most pieces for brassbands are in the keys of G,C,F or Bb. and the fingersetting 1,2 insread of 3 is more comfortable. After a time out of some dekades I’ve started to practice my instrument again and in a Euphonium Bb Solo in D (actually C) I use more often the 3rd valve exactly because of the reasons you’re counting.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    3 hours ago
















2















The trumpet buttons 1,2 and 3 lowers the pitch by 2,1 and 3 halfsteps. So pressing button 1 and 2 gives the same result as only pressing the third button.



So why is the third button so rarely used alone? Why press two buttons instead if you don't have to? I have seen it be used for fast drills that would be almost impossible otherwise, but I cannot understand why it isn't the default for playing the notes E and A.










share|improve this question























  • In my youth and during the military service I always used the fingersttings like you discribed. One reason is mentioned in my answer. Another reason could be that most pieces for brassbands are in the keys of G,C,F or Bb. and the fingersetting 1,2 insread of 3 is more comfortable. After a time out of some dekades I’ve started to practice my instrument again and in a Euphonium Bb Solo in D (actually C) I use more often the 3rd valve exactly because of the reasons you’re counting.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    3 hours ago














2












2








2








The trumpet buttons 1,2 and 3 lowers the pitch by 2,1 and 3 halfsteps. So pressing button 1 and 2 gives the same result as only pressing the third button.



So why is the third button so rarely used alone? Why press two buttons instead if you don't have to? I have seen it be used for fast drills that would be almost impossible otherwise, but I cannot understand why it isn't the default for playing the notes E and A.










share|improve this question














The trumpet buttons 1,2 and 3 lowers the pitch by 2,1 and 3 halfsteps. So pressing button 1 and 2 gives the same result as only pressing the third button.



So why is the third button so rarely used alone? Why press two buttons instead if you don't have to? I have seen it be used for fast drills that would be almost impossible otherwise, but I cannot understand why it isn't the default for playing the notes E and A.







technique trumpet






share|improve this question













share|improve this question











share|improve this question




share|improve this question










asked 4 hours ago









BromanBroman

38213




38213













  • In my youth and during the military service I always used the fingersttings like you discribed. One reason is mentioned in my answer. Another reason could be that most pieces for brassbands are in the keys of G,C,F or Bb. and the fingersetting 1,2 insread of 3 is more comfortable. After a time out of some dekades I’ve started to practice my instrument again and in a Euphonium Bb Solo in D (actually C) I use more often the 3rd valve exactly because of the reasons you’re counting.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    3 hours ago



















  • In my youth and during the military service I always used the fingersttings like you discribed. One reason is mentioned in my answer. Another reason could be that most pieces for brassbands are in the keys of G,C,F or Bb. and the fingersetting 1,2 insread of 3 is more comfortable. After a time out of some dekades I’ve started to practice my instrument again and in a Euphonium Bb Solo in D (actually C) I use more often the 3rd valve exactly because of the reasons you’re counting.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    3 hours ago

















In my youth and during the military service I always used the fingersttings like you discribed. One reason is mentioned in my answer. Another reason could be that most pieces for brassbands are in the keys of G,C,F or Bb. and the fingersetting 1,2 insread of 3 is more comfortable. After a time out of some dekades I’ve started to practice my instrument again and in a Euphonium Bb Solo in D (actually C) I use more often the 3rd valve exactly because of the reasons you’re counting.

– Albrecht Hügli
3 hours ago





In my youth and during the military service I always used the fingersttings like you discribed. One reason is mentioned in my answer. Another reason could be that most pieces for brassbands are in the keys of G,C,F or Bb. and the fingersetting 1,2 insread of 3 is more comfortable. After a time out of some dekades I’ve started to practice my instrument again and in a Euphonium Bb Solo in D (actually C) I use more often the 3rd valve exactly because of the reasons you’re counting.

– Albrecht Hügli
3 hours ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















2














Button=Valve (wind instrument)
Component of brass instruments



Valves are used on brass instruments to change the tube length to allow a chromatic play. When the valve is actuated, the air is passed through an additional pipe loop of a certain length, extending (usually) the air column of the instrument.



The first valve lowers the natural tone by two semitones (12.4%),
The second valve lowers the natural tone by one semitone (6.0%),
The third valve lowers the natural tone by three semitones (19.1%),



Intonation problems:



If two or more valves are used in combination, the intonation of the sound heard does not correspond to the calculated sum of its intervals, but to a tone that is too high. This is because the additional tube length switched by each valve into the resonator body is only calculated to decrease the air column of the open instrument by a certain interval, but does not take into account the air column already extended by another valve.



The intonation when using multiple valves at the same time is therefore basically more or less unclean if no compensation takes place in any form. Quintessence from this realization: The fewer valves are needed, the better the tone is right.



Possible solutions:



There are basically as few valves as possible to use.
With the small differences of the "short" valve combination (1 + 2), the compensation is usually done by ear via the approach.



As you’re supposing:
The use of the clean handle 3 would be desirable, but in practice usually not possible, since in the fingering tables of the instrumental schools and thus in the training, the combination 1 + 2 in the foreground.



For instruments of rather short overall length like the trumpet, the difference in combinations with the third or first valve is usually compensated by simply pulling out the valve train of the third valve.



Therefore cornets, wing horns as well as high-quality tubes and euphoniums have often already standard triggers as an additional intonation aid:



A trigger means a compensation by a device that makes it easier to vary the length of a valve train. This device, also called intonation pusher or equalizer, consists either of a ring connected to the tuning cable or a U-shaped "saddle" which is moved with a finger or of a mechanical lever which is pressed with a finger and usually a return spring has.






share|improve this answer
























  • Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

    – Laurence Payne
    47 mins ago



















1














Because valve #3 is normally tuned slightly flatter than #1 + #2 (and will often have a finger mechanism allowing it to be even flatter). This is to do with the physical fact that each semitone down requires the tube length to increase by the same PROPORTION, not by the same fixed length.



The real situation is complicated by most instruments having finger-operated slides on valves #1 and #3, allowing them to be lengthened. But #3 is still normally adjusted to be longer than the sum of #1 and #2, so it would make notes normally played by #1 + #2 too flat.



On a trumpet without 'triggers', low C# and F#, the only notes requiring #1 + #2 + #3, are, if not un-usable, certainly difficult to play in tune.






share|improve this answer























    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "240"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f80795%2fwhy-is-button-three-on-trumpet-almost-never-used-alone%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    2














    Button=Valve (wind instrument)
    Component of brass instruments



    Valves are used on brass instruments to change the tube length to allow a chromatic play. When the valve is actuated, the air is passed through an additional pipe loop of a certain length, extending (usually) the air column of the instrument.



    The first valve lowers the natural tone by two semitones (12.4%),
    The second valve lowers the natural tone by one semitone (6.0%),
    The third valve lowers the natural tone by three semitones (19.1%),



    Intonation problems:



    If two or more valves are used in combination, the intonation of the sound heard does not correspond to the calculated sum of its intervals, but to a tone that is too high. This is because the additional tube length switched by each valve into the resonator body is only calculated to decrease the air column of the open instrument by a certain interval, but does not take into account the air column already extended by another valve.



    The intonation when using multiple valves at the same time is therefore basically more or less unclean if no compensation takes place in any form. Quintessence from this realization: The fewer valves are needed, the better the tone is right.



    Possible solutions:



    There are basically as few valves as possible to use.
    With the small differences of the "short" valve combination (1 + 2), the compensation is usually done by ear via the approach.



    As you’re supposing:
    The use of the clean handle 3 would be desirable, but in practice usually not possible, since in the fingering tables of the instrumental schools and thus in the training, the combination 1 + 2 in the foreground.



    For instruments of rather short overall length like the trumpet, the difference in combinations with the third or first valve is usually compensated by simply pulling out the valve train of the third valve.



    Therefore cornets, wing horns as well as high-quality tubes and euphoniums have often already standard triggers as an additional intonation aid:



    A trigger means a compensation by a device that makes it easier to vary the length of a valve train. This device, also called intonation pusher or equalizer, consists either of a ring connected to the tuning cable or a U-shaped "saddle" which is moved with a finger or of a mechanical lever which is pressed with a finger and usually a return spring has.






    share|improve this answer
























    • Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

      – Laurence Payne
      47 mins ago
















    2














    Button=Valve (wind instrument)
    Component of brass instruments



    Valves are used on brass instruments to change the tube length to allow a chromatic play. When the valve is actuated, the air is passed through an additional pipe loop of a certain length, extending (usually) the air column of the instrument.



    The first valve lowers the natural tone by two semitones (12.4%),
    The second valve lowers the natural tone by one semitone (6.0%),
    The third valve lowers the natural tone by three semitones (19.1%),



    Intonation problems:



    If two or more valves are used in combination, the intonation of the sound heard does not correspond to the calculated sum of its intervals, but to a tone that is too high. This is because the additional tube length switched by each valve into the resonator body is only calculated to decrease the air column of the open instrument by a certain interval, but does not take into account the air column already extended by another valve.



    The intonation when using multiple valves at the same time is therefore basically more or less unclean if no compensation takes place in any form. Quintessence from this realization: The fewer valves are needed, the better the tone is right.



    Possible solutions:



    There are basically as few valves as possible to use.
    With the small differences of the "short" valve combination (1 + 2), the compensation is usually done by ear via the approach.



    As you’re supposing:
    The use of the clean handle 3 would be desirable, but in practice usually not possible, since in the fingering tables of the instrumental schools and thus in the training, the combination 1 + 2 in the foreground.



    For instruments of rather short overall length like the trumpet, the difference in combinations with the third or first valve is usually compensated by simply pulling out the valve train of the third valve.



    Therefore cornets, wing horns as well as high-quality tubes and euphoniums have often already standard triggers as an additional intonation aid:



    A trigger means a compensation by a device that makes it easier to vary the length of a valve train. This device, also called intonation pusher or equalizer, consists either of a ring connected to the tuning cable or a U-shaped "saddle" which is moved with a finger or of a mechanical lever which is pressed with a finger and usually a return spring has.






    share|improve this answer
























    • Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

      – Laurence Payne
      47 mins ago














    2












    2








    2







    Button=Valve (wind instrument)
    Component of brass instruments



    Valves are used on brass instruments to change the tube length to allow a chromatic play. When the valve is actuated, the air is passed through an additional pipe loop of a certain length, extending (usually) the air column of the instrument.



    The first valve lowers the natural tone by two semitones (12.4%),
    The second valve lowers the natural tone by one semitone (6.0%),
    The third valve lowers the natural tone by three semitones (19.1%),



    Intonation problems:



    If two or more valves are used in combination, the intonation of the sound heard does not correspond to the calculated sum of its intervals, but to a tone that is too high. This is because the additional tube length switched by each valve into the resonator body is only calculated to decrease the air column of the open instrument by a certain interval, but does not take into account the air column already extended by another valve.



    The intonation when using multiple valves at the same time is therefore basically more or less unclean if no compensation takes place in any form. Quintessence from this realization: The fewer valves are needed, the better the tone is right.



    Possible solutions:



    There are basically as few valves as possible to use.
    With the small differences of the "short" valve combination (1 + 2), the compensation is usually done by ear via the approach.



    As you’re supposing:
    The use of the clean handle 3 would be desirable, but in practice usually not possible, since in the fingering tables of the instrumental schools and thus in the training, the combination 1 + 2 in the foreground.



    For instruments of rather short overall length like the trumpet, the difference in combinations with the third or first valve is usually compensated by simply pulling out the valve train of the third valve.



    Therefore cornets, wing horns as well as high-quality tubes and euphoniums have often already standard triggers as an additional intonation aid:



    A trigger means a compensation by a device that makes it easier to vary the length of a valve train. This device, also called intonation pusher or equalizer, consists either of a ring connected to the tuning cable or a U-shaped "saddle" which is moved with a finger or of a mechanical lever which is pressed with a finger and usually a return spring has.






    share|improve this answer













    Button=Valve (wind instrument)
    Component of brass instruments



    Valves are used on brass instruments to change the tube length to allow a chromatic play. When the valve is actuated, the air is passed through an additional pipe loop of a certain length, extending (usually) the air column of the instrument.



    The first valve lowers the natural tone by two semitones (12.4%),
    The second valve lowers the natural tone by one semitone (6.0%),
    The third valve lowers the natural tone by three semitones (19.1%),



    Intonation problems:



    If two or more valves are used in combination, the intonation of the sound heard does not correspond to the calculated sum of its intervals, but to a tone that is too high. This is because the additional tube length switched by each valve into the resonator body is only calculated to decrease the air column of the open instrument by a certain interval, but does not take into account the air column already extended by another valve.



    The intonation when using multiple valves at the same time is therefore basically more or less unclean if no compensation takes place in any form. Quintessence from this realization: The fewer valves are needed, the better the tone is right.



    Possible solutions:



    There are basically as few valves as possible to use.
    With the small differences of the "short" valve combination (1 + 2), the compensation is usually done by ear via the approach.



    As you’re supposing:
    The use of the clean handle 3 would be desirable, but in practice usually not possible, since in the fingering tables of the instrumental schools and thus in the training, the combination 1 + 2 in the foreground.



    For instruments of rather short overall length like the trumpet, the difference in combinations with the third or first valve is usually compensated by simply pulling out the valve train of the third valve.



    Therefore cornets, wing horns as well as high-quality tubes and euphoniums have often already standard triggers as an additional intonation aid:



    A trigger means a compensation by a device that makes it easier to vary the length of a valve train. This device, also called intonation pusher or equalizer, consists either of a ring connected to the tuning cable or a U-shaped "saddle" which is moved with a finger or of a mechanical lever which is pressed with a finger and usually a return spring has.







    share|improve this answer












    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer










    answered 4 hours ago









    Albrecht HügliAlbrecht Hügli

    2,574220




    2,574220













    • Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

      – Laurence Payne
      47 mins ago



















    • Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

      – Laurence Payne
      47 mins ago

















    Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

    – Laurence Payne
    47 mins ago





    Would it be unkind to suspect Albrecht Hügli''s answer reached us via a translation program? He obviously knows his stuff, but it's coming across rather incomprehensibly. And surely "calculated to decrease the air column" should be "calculated to INCREASE the air column"?

    – Laurence Payne
    47 mins ago











    1














    Because valve #3 is normally tuned slightly flatter than #1 + #2 (and will often have a finger mechanism allowing it to be even flatter). This is to do with the physical fact that each semitone down requires the tube length to increase by the same PROPORTION, not by the same fixed length.



    The real situation is complicated by most instruments having finger-operated slides on valves #1 and #3, allowing them to be lengthened. But #3 is still normally adjusted to be longer than the sum of #1 and #2, so it would make notes normally played by #1 + #2 too flat.



    On a trumpet without 'triggers', low C# and F#, the only notes requiring #1 + #2 + #3, are, if not un-usable, certainly difficult to play in tune.






    share|improve this answer




























      1














      Because valve #3 is normally tuned slightly flatter than #1 + #2 (and will often have a finger mechanism allowing it to be even flatter). This is to do with the physical fact that each semitone down requires the tube length to increase by the same PROPORTION, not by the same fixed length.



      The real situation is complicated by most instruments having finger-operated slides on valves #1 and #3, allowing them to be lengthened. But #3 is still normally adjusted to be longer than the sum of #1 and #2, so it would make notes normally played by #1 + #2 too flat.



      On a trumpet without 'triggers', low C# and F#, the only notes requiring #1 + #2 + #3, are, if not un-usable, certainly difficult to play in tune.






      share|improve this answer


























        1












        1








        1







        Because valve #3 is normally tuned slightly flatter than #1 + #2 (and will often have a finger mechanism allowing it to be even flatter). This is to do with the physical fact that each semitone down requires the tube length to increase by the same PROPORTION, not by the same fixed length.



        The real situation is complicated by most instruments having finger-operated slides on valves #1 and #3, allowing them to be lengthened. But #3 is still normally adjusted to be longer than the sum of #1 and #2, so it would make notes normally played by #1 + #2 too flat.



        On a trumpet without 'triggers', low C# and F#, the only notes requiring #1 + #2 + #3, are, if not un-usable, certainly difficult to play in tune.






        share|improve this answer













        Because valve #3 is normally tuned slightly flatter than #1 + #2 (and will often have a finger mechanism allowing it to be even flatter). This is to do with the physical fact that each semitone down requires the tube length to increase by the same PROPORTION, not by the same fixed length.



        The real situation is complicated by most instruments having finger-operated slides on valves #1 and #3, allowing them to be lengthened. But #3 is still normally adjusted to be longer than the sum of #1 and #2, so it would make notes normally played by #1 + #2 too flat.



        On a trumpet without 'triggers', low C# and F#, the only notes requiring #1 + #2 + #3, are, if not un-usable, certainly difficult to play in tune.







        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 3 hours ago









        Laurence PayneLaurence Payne

        35.1k1666




        35.1k1666






























            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f80795%2fwhy-is-button-three-on-trumpet-almost-never-used-alone%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Statuo de Libereco

            Tanganjiko

            Liste der Baudenkmäler in Enneberg